Gawande Authored An Article In 1998 That Used Stigmatizing Language In Its Description Of Abortions That Occur Later In Pregnancy
Gawande Used Extremely Stigmatizing Language In A 1998 Article For Slate. “Every abortion is gross, but the technique is not the issue” [Slate, 1/30/98]
Gawande Described Anti-Choice Ideology As “Seductive”. “Pro-life advocates offer a seductive argument: Whatever you think about abortion in general, partial-birth abortion is just too ghastly to permit. As Republican National Committeeman Tim Lambert argues:, ‘“It is really not about abortion. It’s about infanticide, it’s about a procedure so gruesome the American Medical Association is opposed to it.” Now even strongly pro-choice politicians see this as a no-brainer and may provide enough votes to override President Clinton’s veto of the ban.” [Slate, 1/30/98]
Gawande Seems To Shame People For Not Recognizing They Were Pregnant Earlier. “A few late abortions are done for the mother’s health, to save her, for example, from possible disaster caused by an infected uterus or a newly diagnosed heart condition. Most of the time, however, they are elective. Often, the mother didn’t know she was pregnant. “The power of human denial is unbelievable,” one obstetrician told me. It’s not at all uncommon, he said, to see women go through an entire pregnancy without realizing it, come to the ER with a stomachache, and turn out to be in labor.” [Slate, 1/30/98]
Even When Gawande Attempted To Be Neutral, Stigmatizing Language Was Used. “We need more in-depth study to identify this critical juncture. That’s because most people would feel that it is wrong to do elective abortions–abortions when the health of the mother is not at risk and the fetus is not seriously deformed–beyond that point. The current debate glosses over these issues. There’s no good reason to single out partial-birth abortion–or any technique. From the pro-lifers’ standpoint, banning it will not actually save a single fetus. And for abortion-rights supporters, it is only an invitation to inconsistency.” [Slate, 1/30/98]
In A 2007 New York Times OpEd Gawande Utilized Shame And Stigma To Advocate For Better Sex Education And Reduced Abortion Rates
Gawande Critiqued Politicians’ Reproductive Health Policy By Implying That Abortion Rates Were Too High. “One statistic seems to me to give the lie to all the rhetoric about abortion, and it’s this: one in three women under the age of 45 have an abortion during their lifetime. One in three. All politicians — Democrat and Republican — say they want to make abortion at least rare (as Giuliani did in Wednesday’s debate). On, this they could reach agreement. But it’s clear they haven’t been serious; the U.S. has 1.3 million abortions a year.” [New York Times, 5/19/07]
Gawande Made Stigmatizing Comments Towards Teen Parents. “First, it emphasizes throughout high school that teenagers should wait until they’re older to have sex (because the majority regret not waiting; because having a child as a child wrecks their lives); and second, it makes it clear that when they ultimately have sex, they should always use protection.” [New York Times, 5/19/07]
Gawande Seemed To Imply That Adult Abortion Rates Are “The Issue”. “Fact two follows from this: Abortion is mainly an adult problem. Forty-five percent of abortions occur in adults ages 18 to 24; 48 percent occur after age 25. Most are in women who have already had a child. The kids are all right. We are the issue.” [New York Times, 5/19/07]
Gawande Cited “Blindness” As The Cause Of Birth Control Failure And Negated The Various Clinical Factors That Impact Birth Control Efficiency. “Fact three is that our biggest problem is not using contraception properly: 92 percent of abortions occur in women who said they used birth control. Six in 10 used contraception the month they got pregnant. The others reported that they had used birth control previously but, for one reason or another, not that month. (Many, for example, say they didn’t expect to have sex.) The trouble appears to be blindness to how easy it is to get pregnant and what it takes to make birth control really work.” [New York Times, 5/19/07]
Gawande Proclaimed That Through Education There Is No Reason Anyone Would Have To Join “The One In Three” People Who Will Have An Abortion Before Age 45. “Fact four: you have to educate yourself. The details matter. An effective national campaign would provide the details — on television, on billboards — and actively use what evidence shows works best to cut our massive rate of unwanted pregnancies. But politics precludes this. There’s not going to be such a campaign anytime soon. Nonetheless, there’s no reason you have to join the one in three — or as a male, contribute to it. You just have to understand: the effort is strictly Do-It-Yourself.” [New York Times, 5/19/07]